Personal Injury &
Wrongful Death
Nursing Home
Neglect & Abuse
Hospital Negligence
Motor Vehicle Accidents
Tractor Trailer Accidents
Bus Accidents
Legal Malpractice
Workers’ Compensation
Long Term Disability
[ERISA or IDI / individual]
Personal Injury &
Wrongful Death
Nursing Home
Neglect & Abuse
Hospital Negligence
Motor Vehicle Accidents
Legal Malpractice
Workers’ Compensation
Long Term Care Insurance
Long Term Disability
[ERISA]

Legal Professional?

[Legal News index]

Landmark Ruling re: ERISA subrogation

Dec 21st, 2011

November 16, 2011- A driver was seriously hurt in an accident and agreed to settle for policy limits of $110,000.  His health insurer filed suit and demanded reimbursement for all medical bills it paid related to the accident, an amount that exceeded the driver's net recovery.  


The trial court agreed with the insurer and ordered full reimbursement, leaving nothing for the injured driver.  On appeal, the Third Circuit revered the trial court's decision, and held that when an ERISA Plan's reimbursement language is grossly unfair to the plan participant, the Plan may be modified or reformed to ensure a fair result.

This is the first appellate decision that rejected an insurance company's argument that the Plan language must always be enforced according to its terms.  The case is US Airways, Inc. v. McCutchen, Opinion filed 11/16/11, United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit.


Contact Center


Name

Email

Phone

Questions / Comments:

Reload Image
CAPTCHA Image
Enter Code:

Legal News


Nursing Home ADR Agreement Challenged.
Kentucky Supreme Court to decide if Arbitration Provision is Enforceable.
Read Full Article...

Chain Nursing Homes reduce RN staffing
Direct relationship between adequate staffing of RNs and quality of care provided to nursing home residents.
Read Full Article...

Site by makespace!